9 Tips From A Chef For Making The Best Homemade Pizza

Creating restaurant-quality pizza at home is not just a culinary feat; it’s a journey into the heart of everyone’s favorite comfort food. As someone whose childhood dream was to be a pizza maker, I eventually found myself running a bustling pizza and pasta restaurant. We dedicated ourselves to crafting perfection, making dough from scratch daily, simmering marinara sauce for hours, and selecting only the finest cheeses for our pizzas. The good news is, you can achieve the same level of excellence without the professional kitchen hustle. Here are some insider tips and tricks to elevate your homemade pizza game.

1. Embrace the Power of a Pizza Stone

The Game-Changer:

The secret weapon for achieving the coveted crispiness and fluffiness of restaurant-style pizza is a pizza stone. Commercial pizza ovens reach temperatures over 800ºF, causing a rapid rise in the dough. To replicate this effect at home, invest in a quality pizza stone. This essential tool ensures your pizza crust is perfectly cooked, crispy, and delicious.

Expanding the Insight: A pizza stone is more than a mere accessory; it’s the cornerstone of achieving that authentic, crispy texture in your homemade pizza. The porous nature of the stone absorbs moisture from the dough, resulting in a beautifully crisp crust. As it heats up, it mimics the high temperatures of commercial pizza ovens, allowing your pizza to cook quickly and evenly. Look for a well-made pizza stone that can withstand high temperatures and fits snugly in your home oven for optimal results.

2. Bid Farewell to Tomato Paste

The Upgrade:

Tomato paste has its time and place, but not in pizza sauce. Opt for a simple tomato sauce crafted from tomatoes, onions, garlic, and salt. Ditching the pasty tomato paste results in a fresher and more robust flavor that elevates your pizza to restaurant quality.

Expanding the Insight: The choice of pizza sauce can significantly impact the overall taste of your creation. When crafting a restaurant-quality pizza at home, opt for simplicity and freshness. A tomato sauce made from high-quality ingredients enhances the natural flavors of the pizza. Consider experimenting with different varieties of tomatoes to find the perfect balance of sweetness and acidity. Don’t be afraid to infuse your sauce with herbs like basil and oregano for an extra layer of flavor.

3. Skip the Rolling Pin

The Dough Dilemma:

Whether your dough is homemade or store-bought, avoid the rolling pin unless you’re aiming for an ultra-thin, cracker-like crust. Using a rolling pin expels the gas from the dough, preventing a light and airy crumb. Instead, gently stretch the dough by hand, especially when it’s at room temperature for optimal flexibility.

9 Tips From A Chef For Making The Best Homemade Pizza

Expanding the Insight: The texture of your pizza crust is a delicate dance of ingredients and technique. When it comes to handling the dough, finesse is key. By gently stretching the dough with your hands, you preserve the air pockets, contributing to a lighter, more airy crumb. This method allows you to control the thickness of the crust, ensuring a perfect balance between crispiness and chewiness.

4. Invest in a Pizza Peel

The Easy Slide:

One of the most challenging aspects of homemade pizza is sliding it into the oven. Make this task enjoyable and successful by investing in a pizza peel. Coat it with semolina flour, build your pizza directly on its surface, and effortlessly transfer your creation into the oven.

Expanding the Insight: A pizza peel is the unsung hero that transforms the pizza-making process from daunting to delightful. Its large, flat surface provides ample space for pizza assembly, and the semolina flour prevents sticking. Invest in a quality pizza peel with a comfortable handle for easy maneuvering. Building your pizza directly on the peel not only ensures a seamless transfer into the oven but also adds a professional touch to your home pizza-making experience.

5. Choose Full-Fat Cheeses

The Cheese Affair:

Celebrate the richness of full-flavored, fatty cheeses for a true pizza indulgence. These cheeses melt better than low-moisture alternatives, avoiding the undesirable rubbery texture. Experiment with combinations like mozzarella for meltability and provolone for flavor to find your perfect cheesy blend.

Expanding the Insight: Cheese is the soul of any good pizza, and the choice of cheese can elevate your homemade version to restaurant quality. Opt for full-fat cheeses with rich flavors and excellent meltability. While mozzarella provides that classic stretch, adding provolone or other flavorful cheeses enhances the complexity of the taste. Consider exploring artisanal cheeses for a unique twist that will set your homemade pizza apart.

6. Exercise Topping Restraint

The Art of Balance:

Maintain a balanced pizza by limiting toppings to a maximum of three, following a tried-and-true rule from my restaurant days. After sauce and cheese, a modest selection of toppings allows each flavor to shine, preventing the dough from becoming overly soggy during the cooking process.

Expanding the Insight: In the world of pizza, less is often more. Toppings should complement rather than overpower the flavors of the sauce and cheese. The rule of three ensures a harmonious balance that lets each ingredient shine. Consider selecting fresh, high-quality toppings and experimenting with combinations that create a symphony of flavors on your palate. This approach not only enhances the taste but also ensures a visually appealing pizza.

9 Tips From A Chef For Making The Best Homemade Pizza

7. Avoid Excessive Sauce and Cheese

The Moisture Dilemma:

Resist the temptation to overload your pizza with sauce or cheese. Excessive amounts can introduce excess moisture to the dough, resulting in a soft and soggy crust rather than the desired crispiness. Ensure the dough is still visible after spreading the sauce, and limit the cheese to no more than one cup.

Expanding the Insight: Achieving the perfect balance of sauce and cheese is a delicate dance that determines the texture of your pizza. Applying too much sauce or cheese can lead to a moisture-laden crust, detracting from the overall experience. Use a light hand when spreading the sauce, ensuring it enhances the flavor without overwhelming the crust. Similarly, moderation with cheese allows for proper melting and ensures the crust maintains its desired crispiness.

8. Precook Your Toppings

The Prep Step:

Whether you’re opting for a meatless masterpiece or a carnivorous delight, precook your toppings before they grace the pizza. The home oven might not reach the high temperatures needed to fully cook raw meat, and vegetables benefit from a little par-cooking to avoid unwanted crunchiness.

Expanding the Insight: Precooking toppings serve a dual purpose in the pizza-making process. It ensures that ingredients like raw meats reach a safe internal temperature during the relatively short baking time. Additionally, precooking vegetables prevents them from releasing excess moisture onto the pizza, contributing to a well-balanced texture. Experiment with various cooking techniques to enhance the flavor profile of your toppings, creating a harmonious medley of textures and tastes on your pizza.

9. Practice Patience

The Art of Learning:

Perfecting the art of homemade pizza is a journey that requires practice. Don’t be disheartened if your first attempt doesn’t yield a perfectly shaped pizza. The key is persistence—make more pizza! With each try, it becomes easier, and the reward is a more delicious creation every time.

9 Tips From A Chef For Making The Best Homemade Pizza

Expanding the Insight: Homemade pizza-making is as much about the process as it is about the end result. Embrace the learning curve and view each pizza-making session as an opportunity to refine your skills. From shaping the dough to mastering the art of toppings, every attempt brings you closer to pizza perfection. As you become more familiar with the nuances of the process, you’ll discover your own techniques and preferences, turning each pizza-making session into a delightful culinary adventure.


Transforming your home kitchen into a pizzeria-worthy haven is within reach. By incorporating these tips and tricks, you’ll not only elevate your pizza-making skills but also savor the joy of creating restaurant-quality pizza in the comfort of your home. So, roll up your sleeves, dust off that pizza stone, and embark on a culinary adventure that brings the magic of a pizzeria right to your dining table.

Read Also:- 10 Mistakes You’re Making When You Make Pizza At Home

Leave a comment